Michael Ross has always maintained his innocence following his conviction in 2008 for the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood which occurred in the Orkney Islands in 1994.

The aim of this website is to provide the facts of this case. In doing so, we hope that the public at large will come to see that the conviction of Michael Ross is a catastrophic miscarriage of justice that has destroyed a family, damaged a community and denied justice to the victim of an horrific murder.

If anyone has any information that could assist Michael in the fight to clear his name, please come forward to either the police or campaign group ‘Justice for Michael Ross’.

It’s never too late.


Fundraising Update

January 2018: Our fundraising total now stands at £21,336!

Sculptures exchanged for anonymous donations towards Michael’s £30k legal fees

For further information, click HERE

Fundraising Update

December 2017: The online Crowdfunding campaign has now closed, having raised an amazing total of £18,155. This has been a huge success and we’re not aware of any other miscarriage of justice campaign raising such a substantial sum of money. Michael is now represented by one of Scotland’s foremost Human Rights Law firms, and they are currently familiarising themselves with the complex detail of this case in order to assess any potential progress that could be made. J4MR extend grateful thanks to all of Michael’s loyal supporters.

Watch this space for further fundraising news!



Crowdfunding Launch

20 June 2017: The campaign group have  launched a fundraising appeal in order to attempt to fund the cost of expert legal representation for Michael Ross from a legal firm with a background in Human Rights.

J4MR have been debating a way forward with this for some time as, these days, it seems that just about anyone can set up Crowdfunding with very little monitoring or accountability.

When Alistair Carmichael backed us, we were contacted by Crowdjustice. They do not accept every case; there’s a strict vetting process of the cause, the campaign and legal representation. They will not allow a campaign to go ahead without confirmation that a legal firm are instructed.

They are a unique platform to make justice accessible to all. In an ideal world there wouldn’t be a need for this, but more and more people are ruled out of legal aid.

Crowdjustice will handle everything on our behalf and pay money raised directly to the relevant law firm. This takes away the huge responsibility of handling a large amount of money from us. There’s protection for donors in that, if we don’t reach our initial target in 30 days, no-one will pay anything. This is why it’s crucial that we manage to raise 10k in the 30 day period.

If anyone has any queries at all, please get in touch using the contact form.

Site Updates

We have recently updated the CASE PAGE to show a chronological account of how the case against Michael Ross was built over a 14 year period. You will see that everything about the weak, circumstantial evidence used to convict Michael can be discredited and you will also read some very worrying information that casts doubt on the integrity of the whole police investigation into the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood.

Northern Isles MP and former Scottish Secretary Alistair Carmichael has backed our campaign group ‘Justice for Michael Ross’ in our quest to ensure that the wrongful conviction of Michael Ross is not swept under the carpet.

Mr Carmichael has criticised the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission in their handling of two reviews they have completed on the case. He says that the SCCRC have “not properly engaged with concerns raised” and that the conclusions reached were “not as clear as I would expect them to be.”

Mr Carmichael, who is a former solicitor and depute procurator fiscal, also went on to say that J4MR had raised “legitimate concerns” about the police investigation into the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood.

BBC Scotland website, 15th September 2016: Click HERE to view article

‘The Orcadian’ Exclusive 15th September 2016: For the option to purchase, click HERE

Herald Scotland website, 14th September 2016: Click HERE to view article

Press and Journal website, 14th September 2016: Click HERE to view article

Scottish Legal News website, 14th September 2016: Click HERE to view article

The Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission began reviewing Michael’s case in December 2012 and completed the review in November 2015, just short of 3 years later. Follow the link to read the perspective of the campaign group on the deficiencies of the desktop review performed by the SCCRC:

Open letter and Report from J4MR to the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission – February 2016

The Orcadian website, 28th March 2016: Click HERE to view article

BBC Website, 28th March 2016: Click HERE to view page

Press and Journal website, 28th March 2016: Click HERE to view article

Case Background

The Mumutaz restaurant, Kirkwall
The Mumutaz restaurant, Kirkwall

Over 20 years ago on 2nd June 1994, at just after 7pm in the evening, a masked man calmly entered the Mumutaz Indian restaurant in the small town of Kirkwall in the Orkney Islands. He walked up to a young waiter named Shamsuddin Mahmood and shot him at point blank range in the head. The restaurant was busy with customers, including young children.

The gunman was masked and unrecognisable. He was confident and quick. He never faltered and was able to make good his escape by running away down the lane to the right of the restaurant never to be seen again.


Orkney MapThe Orkney Islands  are situated six miles north of the Scottish mainland. The peaceful island community had a population of around 20,000 in 1994 and, at that time, there hadn’t been a murder there for 26 years. A murder inquiry team were brought north from Inverness to take over the responsibility for the investigation.

Early reports indicated that police were looking for a ‘man’ and there was speculation that the murder resembled a contract killing.  Eyewitness testimony led the police to issue a description of the gun-man as aged in his late 20’s, approximately 5’8” – 6’ tall, with “hunched” or rounded shoulders, a body builders pose and confident stride.


Michael Ross (left) at age 16
Michael (left) aged 16


In June 1994, Michael Ross was just 15 years old. He could have been no taller than 5’7½ then, because this is the height that he is today, as a grown man. This is a photograph of Michael and his younger brother taken in 1995 when he was 16, several months after the murder of Mr Mahmood .

His brother, also featured, is 20 months younger than Michael and would have been around 14 years old. It is clear that he has overtaken Michael in height. The decorative block in the wall next to Michael is 12″ or a foot square, therefore it is possible to roughly estimate Michael’s height as around 5’7″. There is no documented source stating his height in June 1994 the previous year; however you will find video footage of young Michael in the MEDIA section of the website.


PC Eddy Ross on duty with Northern Constabulary
PC Eddy Ross on duty with Northern Constabulary


At an early point in the investigation, police began to suspect Michael Ross of the crime. He had been seen and recognised in a wooded area of Kirkwall on 19th May 1994, 2 weeks prior to the murder wearing a balaclava.

His father, Eddy Ross, who was a policeman, found one full sealed box of bullets within his stocks similar to those used in the crime.

He voluntarily handed them in to colleagues at the police station on 12th August 1994, 10 weeks after the crime. At that time, Eddy had served in the police force for 20 years with an unblemished record. He was also an amateur gun enthusiast, gun club member, firearms licence holder and army cadet leader. He’d served in the army for 5 years prior to joining the police.




Sgt Michael Ross
Sgt Michael Ross


Police prepared a report on Michael Ross for the Procurator Fiscal in July 1995; however, charges were never brought against him because there was insufficient evidence. Rumours and gossip were rife in the small community. Eddy Ross was convicted of ‘Perverting the Course of Justice’ in May 1997 in connection with the bullets he had voluntarily submitted to the investigation. He served 2 years of a 4 year prison sentence.

Michael Ross went on and built a life for himself. He went into the Black Watch Regiment and rose to the rank of sergeant. He married and had two daughters. He was well liked and popular in his regiment just as he’d been well liked at school and by his neighbours and friends in Orkney.  He received a mention in ‘Despatches’ for bravery in Iraq, where he saw heavy combat and lost close friends.


The Anonymous Letter handed in to Kirkwall Police Station on 6th September 2006
The Anonymous Letter

In September 2006 an ‘eyewitness’ presented an anonymous letter to Orkney police, 12 years after the murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood. He told police that he’d seen Michael Ross on the evening of the murder in the Kiln Corner public toilets near the crime scene wearing a balaclava and holding a gun. He also claimed he’d seen Michael Ross a few weeks earlier shouting racist abuse and threats of violence outside the Mumutaz restaurant. Neither he nor anyone else had reported either event to police at the time or from 1994 to 2006.

On 20 June 2008, 14 years after the crime, Michael Ross was convicted of murder at the High Court in Glasgow. He is currently serving a life sentence. There was no connection between Michael Ross and the victim. There was no forensic evidence to connect him to the crime. There was not one single eyewitness that could place him anywhere near the crime scene from 1994 – 2006.


Eddy Ross, Armistice Day 2015
Eddy Ross, Armistice Day 2015

Michael is currently serving a life sentence for murder at Shotts Prison in Lanarkshire. Every attempt he has made to clear his name has been blocked. Eddy Ross, now retired, currently serves as Chairman for the Kirkwall branch of the Royal British Legion Scotland.

The support that Michael and his family have received from the Orkney community and beyond has kept them going in their fight to clear the names of the father and son whose lives have been tarnished by the tragedy of wrongful conviction.

We hope that you will make time to read and absorb the information contained on this website and join Michael and his family in their fight against this miscarriage of justice.


Thank-you for taking an interest.



All information given on this site is factual, thoroughly researched and can be verified with supporting documentation. Further information will be added to the site in due course.



  • Spread the word about the case across social media and by speaking to your friends, family and acquaintances
  • Write to your MP and MSP as well as the Justice Secretary of Scotland to express concern about the conviction
  • Sign the PETITION requesting action from the Justice Secretary of Scotland
  • Ask your trade union, church group or community group to take an interest – speak to J4MR about providing a presentation on the facts of the case
  • Write to Michael:  Michael Ross 108649, HMP Shotts, Canthill Road, New Mains, Lanarkshire ML7 4LE